Sir Harry Oakes Murder Mystery

On July 8, 1943, Nassau became the epicenter of an investigation into the brutal murder of Sir Harry Oakes. American-born, Oakes made his wealth in Canada before moving to The Bahamas for tax purposes in the 1930s. Oakes, at the time, was a part of Nassau’s elite. He played a significant role in expanding Nassau’s first airport, Oakes Field Airport, and by the early 1940s, Oakes owned approximately one-third of New Providence. His murder, and the subsequent trial of his son-in-law, laid out the corruption and coercion that dominated Nassau’s elite, for all the world to see.

In 1942, Alfred de Marigny married Oakes’ oldest daughter, Nancy Oakes, two days after her 18th birthday. Alfred and Nancy lived in Villa Doyle, the current home to the National Art Gallery of the Bahamas. Harry did not approve of their marriage, as de Marigny was twice divorced and fourteen years older than Nancy. De Marigny became the primary suspect in Sir Harry Oakes’ murder when his fingerprint was found on a screen in Oakes’ bedroom. 

The investigation was led by the then-Bahamian governor, the Duke of Windsor. The Duke requested that two Miami-based police officers assist local law enforcement with the investigation. Upon arrival in Nassau, the Miami police reported that they forgot their fingerprint kits, and unfortunately, none were available in Nassau. Eventually, it was discovered that de Marigny’s print had actually been lifted from a water glass he used during questioning with the Miami police. De Marigny was then acquitted of the murder charge, as it was clear he was being framed.

What remains a mystery today is who sought to frame de Marigny and why. In “Blood and Fire,” a book by John Marquis, Marquis argues that the murder was planned by white Nassau elites to prevent Oakes from moving his money and investments to Mexico. Marquis’ evidence implicates Sir Harold Christie, the person to report Oakes dead in the plot, and places blame on the Duke of Windsor for developing the cover-up that framed de Marigny.

Photo: New York Times, July 9, 1943.

Jimmy Wells and the Bluebelle Incident

Sandy Point, Abaco resident, Jimmy Wells, assisted Julian Harvey with crew duties when the Bluebelle docked in Abaco sometime around November 11-12, 1961. The Bluebelle, with the Duperrault and Harvey families on board, had set sail from Fort Lauderdale on the 8th of November for a weeklong cruise around the Bahama Islands. During their stop in Abaco, they invited Jimmy on board for dinner, although at the time, Jimmy was unaware that he would be the last person to see most of the family alive.

The Bluebelle sank approximately 14 miles from the Great Stirrup Cay Lighthouse on the night of November 12, 1961. The U.S. Coast Guard rescued Harvey, who claimed to be the sole survivor of the vessel. Harvey stated that the boat caught ablaze around 11 pm, and he was unable to save the Duperraults nor his wife. 

Days after Harvey’s rescue, Terry Jo Duperrault, the youngest member of the Duperrault family, was found adrift. Terry Jo, at 11 years old, recalled the horrors of her last night on the Bluebelle: Harvey, she said, had murdered his wife and her family. Following this allegation, Julian Harvey committed suicide. The investigation concluded that Harvey did kill the Duperraults and his wife, and then intentionally sunk the Bluebelle after escaping on a dinghy. 

It is unclear if these photographs were taken as a part of the official investigation, or simply a journalistic publication, but LIFE Magazine photographer Michael Rougier captured them in 1961.